A Historical, Cross-Cultural Perspective
Western pharmacology and Chinese herbology share the same root; the
manipulation of plants, minerals and animals to treat illness. In fact, the
early theoretical platforms for both medicines are also shared as the
philosophy of health and disease suggested by Hypocrites and later
Paracelsus have many parallels with that of Chinese medicine and the great
physicians of China.
The Father of Western Medicine
Hypocrites was born on the island of Cos, Greece in 460BC and although
little is known about the specifics of his life, his influence in
transitioning medicine out of the arena of philosophy and spirit into the
world of experimentation and logic was great in addition to his
contributions as a geometrist. It has been suggested in fact, that he was
born to a family directly descendant from Aesculapius, the son of Apollo. He
was a student of Herodicus and gained a great understanding of medicine from
extensive travels. He was the first physician to diagnose disease, namely
epilepsy and pneumonia and had a very pragmatic approach to preventative
health which included getting enough rest, washing and eating well. He is
famous for saying "nothing to excess" as the basis for a long life and it is
suggested that he himself lived to be well over one hundred years old.
The importance of his work is exemplified by the universal use of his
beautiful code of ethics for physicians, which is still used to this day and
the acknowledgement as the "Father of Modern medicine." He is recognized as
authoring what is called the "Hippocratic Corpus," a collection of sixty
heterogeneous medical treatises compiled in Hellenistic times, although he
is sure to have only contributed a small portion of the total compilation.
Among those treatises where revolutionary concepts such as preventative
medicine. For instance, "Regimen and Regimen in Acute Disease" correlated
diet and lifestyle to illness. "Airs, Waters and Places" linked
environmental factors to disease etiology and "Prognostics", "Coan
Prognosis," and "Aphorisms" discussed disease prognosis and prediction based
on clinical experience. The following is a select list of medical comments
made in the treatise "Aphorisms":
"Life is short, art is long, occasion sudden, experiment dangerous, judgment
difficult. Neither is it sufficient that the physician do his office, unless
the patient and his attendants do their duty and external conditions are
well ordered."
"In extreme diseases extreme and searching remedies are best."
"Old men easily endure fasting, middle-aged men not so well, young men still
less easily, and children worst of all, especially those who are of a more
lively spirit."
"Those bodies that grow have much natural heat, therefore they require good
store of food or else the body consumes, but old men have little heat in
them, therefore they require but little food, for much nourishment
extinguishes that heat. And this is the reason that old men do not have very
acute fevers, because their bodies are cold."
"Those things that are or have been justly determined by nature ought not to
be moved or altered, either by purging or other irritating medicine, but
should be let alone."
"Sleeping or walking, if either be immoderate, is evil."
"It is dangerous much and suddenly either to empty, heat, fill, or cool, or
by any other means to stir the body, for whatever is beyond moderation is an
enemy to nature; but that is safe which is done little by little, and
especially when a change is to be made from one thing to another."
"Changes of seasons are most effectual causes of diseases, and so are
alterations of cold and heat within the seasons, and other things
proportionately in the same manner."
"And in what part of the body there is unusual heat or cold there the disease
is seated."
"The same meat administered to a person sick of a fever as to one in health
will strengthen the healthy one, but will increase the malady of the sick
one."
"The finishing stroke of death is when the vital heat ascends above the
diaphragm and all the moisture is dried up. But when the lungs and heart
have lost their moisture, the heat being all collected together in the most
mortal places, the vital fire by which the whole structure was built up and
held together is suddenly exhaled. Then the soul leaving this earthly
building makes its exit partly through the flesh and partly through the
openings in the head, by which we live; and thus it surrenders up this cold
earthly statue, together with the heat, blood, tissues, and flesh."
Within this list of statements is a fascinating conceptual framework for a
newly found medicine free from superstition and devastating actions of
divine will. Here we see guidelines for the medical practitioner based on
the theories of seasons and temperature, age, diet and fasting and the death
process itself. This broad spectrum of commentary and clinical observation
created an important foundation for modern medicine to move in the direction
of scientific protocol and also very similar to how a Chinese medical
practitioner would view a medical condition, make a diagnosis and create a
treatment protocol. However, during the Renaissance, a shift occurred with
the work of Paracelsus.
Paracelsus (1493-1541)
Paracelsus created an alternative model to the traditional Galenic system of
humoral imbalances during the Renaissance period in Europe. He was a Swiss
physician who attempted to generate a mind-body medicine based on alchemical
principles utilizing salt, sulfur and mercury in addition to maintaining a
strong commitment to experimental medicine in an age of magic based healing.
Born in Eisiedeln, Switzerland to a poor German physician and chemist he
was home schooled in botany, chemistry, metallurgy and medicine and then
graduated by the age of 17 from the University of Vienna with a degree in
medicine. He then traveled as a student through Egypt, Arabia, Mesopotamia,
and Europe seeking the knowledge in alchemy and medicine.
He gained much recognition using unconventional treatments that manipulated
various minerals and is noted for discovering the element zinc. For example,
he treated and cured syphilis using mercury and also made pills that
contained minute traces of a person's feces in his remedy for plague. His
opinion on trauma and wound care was to keep the area from becoming infected
and mostly to provide proper drainage that would allow for the area to heal
on it's own. This was in contrast to the standard procedure of cauterizing
with boiling water and amputation following gangrene.
He acknowledged a relationship between man and the planetary forces that
surround us and used astrological information as an important component in
creating his treatment strategy. His belief in the mind-body relationship
is illustrated in the following statement,
"Man is not body. The heart, the spirit, is man.
And this spirit is an entire star, out of which,
he is built. If therefore a man is perfect in his
heart, nothing in the whole light of Nature is
hidden from him."
In effect, he is stating in my opinion what many of the eastern philosophies
propose, that the suffering of man, be it mental or physical, can be cured
by discovering one's true self, a limitless experience of wisdom and
compassion which begins by opening or connecting to one's own heart. This
hypothesis for him, as an alchemist, was fueled by a search for the
fundamental element of all creation that would prove to be a universal
medicine.
He surely brings to the arena of Renaissance medicine a mixture of many
elements both scientific and spiritual which is what surely sparked much of
the controversy around his many writings. A great intellectual and to a
certain extent, a theologian, Paracelsus was truly interested in creating a
holistic approach to medicine. His interests ranged from miners diseases and
venereal disease to theorizing about the etiology of the plague and the
curative powers of mineral water. In addition, his notions about the spirit,
astrology, and other unorthodox views in relation to medicine mixed together
with his own reactionary temperament and anti-Galenic attitudes all lead to
a life of mixed publicity and approval. His writings were difficult to have
published and he in fact spent most of his life wandering from place to
place studying and practicing a poor physician. Respect for his discoveries
and chemical treatment of disease were not really respected and honored
until well after his death.
For the last five hundred years, however, beginning with the work of
Paracelsus, there has been a movement away from the concept of health as a
natural extension of balance. Paracelus created a new concept of working
with particular diseases treating with a specific remedy rather than
treating from a humoral perspective. This shift initiated a new evolutionary
trend that moved away from a holistic model of medicine into a
reductionistic one. In addition, advancements in anatomy (Andreas Vesalius,
1453), in the physiology of the circulatory system (William Harvey, 1616),
Pasteur's Germ Theory (1822-1895), Joseph Lister's contribution of
connecting microbes with wound sepsis and developing the use of carbonic
acid during surgery for prevention (1877), Robert Koch's (1893) work in
bacteriological research on anthrax, typhus and tuberculosis and Alexander
Flemming's (1929) discovery of penicillin all nurtured the new direction of
medicine right into the twenty-first century.
Where does herbology fit into all this?
The use of herbs in Western medicine has continued into the present but the
focus of how herbs are used has changed and the form we take them in, as
pills, fosters a disconnection with the original form of the medicine. The
result is that we don't know where our medicine is coming from and herbology
itself, the use of these amazing substances in their natural state, gets
forgotten, belittled and ignored. The following is a list of a few powerful
and common medicines that have an herbal root:
Digitalis, purple foxglove was discovered by Dr. William Withering who learned of the herb from a local gypsy-herbalist. It is a cardiotonic drug,
a steroid that effects the heart muscle and has been used since 1775. Today
it comes in a form called Digitoxin or Digoxin and is used to control
heartrate.
In Chinese Medicine, we use the root of the foxglove, sheng di huang, "fresh
earth yellow" to treat conditions related to the blood.
Aspirin, originally from meadowsweet and white willow tree bark, the active ingredient is salicin which the body converts into salicylic acid.
Salicylic acid in white willow bark lowers the body's levels of
prostaglandins, hormonelike compounds that are associated with aches, pain,
and inflammation. While white willow bark takes longer to begin acting than
aspirin, its effect may last longer. In addition, it doesn't cause stomach
bleeding or other known adverse effects that may occur with synthetic
aspirin use.
All aspirin is now chemically synthesized.
In Chinese medicine, white willow bark has been used for hundreds of years
to relieve pain and lower fever.
Morphine, from the poppy, Papaver Somniferous, it is a potent narcotic analgesic, and its primary clinical use is in the management of moderately severe and severe pain. Morphine is isolated from crude opium, which is a resinous preparation of the opium poppy, and prescribed in drug form as
Roxinal, MS Contain, and Morphine Sulfate.
Penicillin, produced from molds, kills by preventing some bacteria from forming new cell walls. In the Us alone, infectious bacterial diseases are
only 1/20 of what they were in 1900 because of medicines like penicillin.
The first major Chinese text describing the actions and functions of herbs
was compiled by a famous Taoist, Tao Hong-Jing (452-536A.D.) This text, the
Divine Husbandman's Classic of the Material Medica had 364 entries and
described the therapeutic properties of the medicinals and the proper
preparation for each. By 1596, the Grand Materia Media contained a thorough
description of 1,892 substances and in 1977, the Encyclopedia of Traditional
Chinese Medicinal Substances was published which includes 5,767 entries.
Herbs are categorized into eight different therapeutic methods.
They are:
Warm the Interior
Increase Circulation
Clear Heat or Infection
Reduce or Eliminate Accumulations in the body such as clots, phlegm, or
water
Tonifying or Nourishing Weakness in the body
Promote Sweating
Induce Vomiting
Induce Defecation
Herbal formulas are then designed to remove stagnation, support
deficiencies, remove obstructions, weigh down anxieties, dry up damp
conditions like edema and moisten dry conditions. With the exception of
vomiting, we continue to use all of these treatment strategies in modern
Chinese medicine.
Herbs are prescribed to exactly match diagnosed patterns of disharmony.
Formulas traditionally include between 7 and 15 different herbs on average.
The goal of any prescription is to address as many symptoms as possible
while maintaining a balanced integrity. Chinese herbs when properly
prescribed do not produce side effects. They can act very much like a
dietary supplement with the strength and precision to eliminate our
ailments, nourish our bodies and prevent illness.
There are many different types of herbal prescriptions. Herbs may be
prepared as raw decoctions, that is, a grouping of twigs, leaves, roots, and
flowers which are boiled in water until a thick soup is created. Prepared
liquid extracts, pills, and powders are also available. Because there are
many different kinds of people with different needs, Chinese medicine
attempts to offer a wide range of options for treatment. |